First of all the good:I was impressed by how many dances the cafe members learned this year. I bet it was a lot of hard work. It was also good to put it at the end of the masquerade to keep people there while waiting for the judges to get done deliberating.
Also thank you SO MUCH for playing Caramelldansen at the informal dance after the masquerade. I know maybe some con vets are sick of it (somehow...not sure how since I'm not years later), but I love how everyone can participate and geek out to it because we all know the dance for it, even if it is a little silly. (Small criticism: use the foreign version, that was an English-lyric version)
Then I like how Jessiy got everyone to dance together to different songs and took requests and such. Even if it was simple moves, it probably relieved some awkward tension of some who think they can't dance or are too embarrassed to. Or at least was an icebreaker to get them to loosen up and dance freestyle to other songs; helped me to anyway. Oh and giving out glowsticks was fun too : ).
Precious Cosplay was an awesome guest. No offense, but the cosplay guests you had last year seemed a bit...full of themselves and gave off an "I'm important, so your questions are unimportant" vibe. These two though were enthusiastic, willing to hear you out no matter the question, and despite y'know being professionals and having their own image to promote, they were friendly, approachable and took a picture with you if you asked.
Food room was a great idea again, but if it’s taking up a lot of the budget that maybe could be used to get a VA guest or something…hm. Speaking of, maybe try to get Warky! He lives in Nevada now, so maybe he wouldn’t charge much for coming. Like how the food was less limited this time too though.
Iron Mecha cosplay seemed like a lot of fun, I wish I got there sooner to participate myself. My suggestion to make it more fun though is I dunno...play mecha anime AMVs in the background or something while the groups are constructing. Also if you could spray paint the cardboard different colors before the event that'd be sweet. Also after the battle have a showdown to see which one stands up the best in battle or a race or something. Then give a prize out to the group who won : ).
I'm glad there was a prize for the SSBB tournament at least at the awards ceremony this year. It's nice that those who aren't good at cosplay or whatever else can get recognized for the talents too.
The PJ party/Takarazuka thing was brilliant and a heck of a lot of fun. What made it great was that adult otakus with more mature anime tastes could make jokes and talk about more adult subjects freely without worrying about getting kicked out. But most of all, it was awesome to just watch something awesome and discuss it/make comments about it along the way. I'd love to see something like this happen again next year, but maybe show I dunno 18+ AMVs or sample a bunch of abridged series or something.
Secondly, the bad: The schedule was a mess to put it politely. I had no idea what was going on and when it was going on. I imagine you did this to save money in your budget, but even if that's the case, a more detailed master schedule should've appeared on the big poster behind the registration table. Here's what I think could've made it better:
-Put the actual times next to all events listed. It was confusing to flip the page and try to line it up correctly, especially since Friday’s Events/Panels listings were printed slightly off. I think just putting the times twice, oh and putting all of Friday on one side, all of Saturday on the other would’ve been so much more convenient.
-Some panels/events reading the titles isn't enough. Like for instance, if I've never been to a con before in my life and saw an event called, "So you think you can sparkle?" I'd be like what the heck is that? And when people don't know, they don't go usually.
-I had no clue the AMV showing this year was Friday at 5pm. It wasn’t on the schedule printed and a sign telling us about it wasn’t put up til quite a while later. I’m quite disappointed that I didn’t get to see them. Also that was placed around a time other big events were
-Also I didn’t know what animes were playing at what times in the viewing room either. I remember back in…2010 I think, you guys had a 9pm Spice and Wolf episodes 1 & 2 being shown or whatever ones they were.
Having this information is good for two reasons: one, you know the title of the anime you’re watching in case you’re interested in checking it out later. Two, you can look at the schedule and see oh I’ve seen that one, so I’ll do something else at that time. That also lets you see oh I haven’t seen that and the title sounds interesting, so I’ll go check it out.
-I had no idea when the dealer’s room and artist alley opened/closed either, so I couldn’t plan my attendance to different things accordingly.
-I had no idea there was an origami workshop or that the board room was being utilized this year until I went around the corner and saw a sign. So adding that to the schedule would be good as well.
-Putting deadlines of when you gotta sign up for chess, masquerade, etc would be good as well.
Another thing I was really disappointed about was the enforcement of formal-attire only at the ball dance. I wanted to at least see the characters do a dance skit and watch from the sidelines like I did last year. And some people (like me) decided to come down at the very last minute (10pm Thursday 4 hour drive down to St George) and didn’t think to pack a skirt or whatever real quickly. Or again, people unfamiliar with cons wouldn’t necessarily know beforehand it was formal wear only.
I went by the tent at the very last minute because I wanted to see my friends dancing in there through the tent window, and found out to my surprise you decided to let non-formally dressed people in. If I knew that I would’ve came around sooner and I ended up missing most of Jupiter’s performance
. Speaking of which though, I heard a lot of people left the ball as soon as Jupiter started playing. What’s the deal with that? I hope they weren’t offended or anything, and if I knew I could’ve came in when they started playing, I would’ve. So if there’s a way to y’know get people to stay for their performance, that’d be cool.
A small criticism I have about the maid café is due to them not being in their character cosplays, it was hard to tell who was what character. Took me forever to realize oh hey so and so’s Syaoran and that one’s Sakura. Then as well as the maid cafe dancers did, dancing is only entertaining for so long without a plot of some sort. Well I guess it's entertaining if it's like...a pro pop-idol concert or something. So I think a skit or having a story in between dances would be more ideal to keeping people engaged. Because I dunno about anyone else, but I was getting a little bored, especially with the length of one of those songs…wow I was like alright I get it.
My other criticism of the masquerade was it was so hard to understand what Sarah, Rufus and Ronni were saying in between skits or to set up the masquerade. I know it's nerve-wracking and such to talk on the spot, but I think the main problem was enunciation. The tone of voices weren't always very clear. Also after watching the skit/walk-on, I wanted to know what series and what character each person was playing, but sometimes it didn't get mentioned. So if you could remember to mention those details next time that'd be awesome.
Suggestions for improvement:Honestly I think you guys weened off Anime Vegas a little too soon. They provided people to do stuff like that vocaloid skit in 2011 (or maybe that wasn't them), as well as resources to get even one voice acting guest. Then again, I'm not sure if you can ask them to help you guys out again or not financially, so this may be useless to point out.
I personally would like to see battle cosplay come back. Y'know where you play fight and do x damage and such. If we could get music playing while it's going on, I think that'd make it more popular maybe?
On that note though, more variety of panels! Yeah it’s probably due to your lack of panel volunteers, but still, maybe schedule an hour or so where it’s free-for-all fandom discussion panel. Have someone moderate it, but then just ask people what anime they wanna talk about or bring up random questions or topics to discuss. On the fly stuff like that can turn out pretty fun, and if it gets ugly, well that’s what the moderators would be there for. Or break it down into genres: slice of life fan panel discussion, mecha discussion, magical girl discussion.
If you can’t get more panels, then at least work on making some events more interesting. Stuff like Iron Mecha and So you think you can Sparkle have a lot of downtime, so it would be cool if you could think of stuff to do in the downtime. Props to Sparkle for improvising the entertainment though. Ooo hey idea for Iron Mecha cosplay: have the audience throw out suggestions for something the teams have to add to their mecha, like a décor of a butterfly or butt rockets. That’d be interesting.
Another thing you may want to consider for an event, anime/video game themed party games. For instance, red light/green light, but Metal Gear Solid style. So people walk forward in a cardboard box when it’s green light, then stop when it’s red light. Then maybe a giant Mario Kart theme game where you tie balloons to people’s ankles, and the person who hasn’t had all 3 balloons popped (you pop each other’s via stomping) at the end wins something. Maybe a sports day basket ball toss thing they do in an anime I saw once…they tossed like ping-pong stuff into a basket. Team with the most balls in it wins.
Oh and I remember in 2011 the karaoke thing you guys did. That was a pretty cool idea…did it get bad feedback though? Seemed people were into it iirc.
- - -
Well I think that’s all I have to say for now; I’ll post again if I think of anything else. Overall yeah the dealers room wasn’t as diverse as last year; the artist alley was better this year though. And yeah I dunno what it is or why it is, but I agree a little bit with Temari. Maybe it’s because I didn’t cosplay this year or last year or something. Or maybe it’s cause there wasn’t cute dancing Totoro and impromptu dance sessions in the hall. Or maybe it’s because I don’t think I can have a funner time than I had in 2011 when my friend and I won best in show. Sean Schemmel was very inspirational as well. Also call me crazy, but when the masquerade was in the two-room place with a little stage, it made the quality of everything better somehow. For some reason all that empty space in the tent unnerves me, and on an unconscious level it might repel people. Sure the little main events room in the hotel was crowded, but it gave ya a, "wow we’re all here for the love of anime" cozy feeling.
I think that last bias may be it…I was spoiled rotten in 2011, and it’s stupid to expect the same level of awesome every time. But it’s human nature unfortunately I guess. It’s the little charms I mentioned last paragraph though that make this little con so great, like the Totoro and intimate cosplay setting. And if Fannatiku’s taught me anything, it’s that smaller cons can be better than bigger cons.
Also, I hope this review doesn't reflect badly on me on any of you guys. I know you guys work really hard to put this on every year, and I freaking love Natalie, Sarah, Jessiy and the others; people who I had the privilege to interview and get to know better last year. Maybe this review's got a negative overtone because I'm taking out my frustration out on you guys for my inability to maintain that bond of friendliness and camaraderie I had last con with you guys.
Thanks so much for letting me interview you guys last year btw. Sorry it didn't really go anywhere though and I didn't end up writing a big grand article. I'm still a journalist novice and all that information I gathered overwhelmed me; I was like gaaah whatdoIdo, whatdoIsay? Still I think it was good experience for interviewing/taking notes and such.